William Katz:  Urgent Agenda

HOME      ABOUT      OUR ARCHIVE      CONTACT 

 

 

 

 

11:55 P.M. ET:  The first debate poll is out from CNN.  It has Clinton winning, 52-39.  But we should point out that CNN's polls always have Clinton winning debates, so I don't attach too much significance to them.  Besides, 52% isn't much of a number for someone who, presumably, is the leading presidential candidate.

The big story is still Trump's blunder.  Most news organizations we've checked are leading their coverage with that:  Trump's announcement that he might not accept the result of the election. 

In 1976, incumbent President Gerald R. Ford committed a similar blunder in a debate with Jimmy Carter.  Ford said that Poland was a free nation.  Of course, it wasn't.  The blunder cost Ford dearly.  It made him seem uninformed, and it infuriated families that had escaped Eastern Europe.  Carter, much to our regret, went on to victory.

The conventional wisdom that I'm hearing tonight is that Trump's blunder destroyed an otherwise good performance.  We'll see.  The public has a way of surprising us.   

 

11:08 P.M. ET:  A number of first impressions are in from the debate.  There's a general (not unanimous) feeling that Trump had a good night on most issues, but that, once again, he committed serious unforced errors that compromised his performance.  The big headline is his statement that he might not accept the results of the election.  Whaa..?  That's the kind of statement you only make after the election if there's clear proof of fraud, and fraud sufficient to affect the outcome.  Even some Trump supporters among the punditry winced. Trump seemed to be showing contempt for American democracy.

Also, Trump, toward the end, referred to Clinton as a "nasty woman."  Absolutely unnecessary.  Let the public make that judgment.  If she's nasty, they'll know it.  Trump merely called attention to his own problems with women.

As for Clinton, the first impressions are bland.  She held her own.  She didn't make any brilliant points, and, as Brit Hume pointed out, clearly directed her comments to her own constituencies – blacks, women, LGBT, other minorities.  Hers was a kind of "get out the vote" performance.  No one is raving.   She's Hillary.   She doesn't dazzle or move audiences.

On balance, Trump could have claimed a victory, but his unforced errors muddy the waters.  We're looking forward to the first polls.

October 19, 2016